Constitutional Law Reporter

FEBRUARY 28, 2024

Supreme Court held that a consumer may sue a federal agency under 15 U.S.C. §§ 1681n and 1681o for failing to comply with the terms of the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA). While the District Court sided with the USDA, the Third Circuit Court of Appeals reversed. Kirtz , 601 U.S. _ (2024), the U.S. government.

Court Rules 52

Court Rules Court Cause of Action Statute 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

MARCH 30, 2023

Supreme Court sided with John Montenegro Cruz, a death row inmate in Arizona. According to a 5-4 majority, Arizona erred in refusing to apply the Court’s precedent set forth in Simmons v. The trial court and Arizona Supreme Court held that Arizona’s capital sentencing scheme did not trigger application of Simmons.

Court 52

Court Court Decisions Laws Constitutional Law 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

APRIL 10, 2024

Supreme Court ruled that public officials may be held liable for their social media activity in certain circumstances. The District Court found that because Freed managed his Facebook page in his private capacity, and because only state action can give rise to liability under §1983, Lindke’s claim failed. In Lindke v.

Court 52

Court Cause of Action Government Court Rules 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

MAY 30, 2023

Supreme Court’s decision in Axon Enterprise, Inc. Federal Trade Commission , 598 U.S. _ (2023), allows federal district courts to consider constitutional challenges to administrative proceedings prior to the issuance of final rulings. Cochran’s and Axon’s suits were both dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.

Court 52

Court Constitutional Law Entertainment Administrative Law 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

SEPTEMBER 12, 2023

Supreme Court held that a plaintiff alleges a “domestic injury” as mandated under RJR Nabisco, Inc. The District Court initially froze Yegiazaryan’s California assets before finally entering judgment against him. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed. Supreme Court’s Decision The Supreme Court affirmed.

Court 52

Court Laws Real Estate Constitutional Law 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

SEPTEMBER 8, 2023

Supreme Court upheld a federal law that criminalizes “encouraging or inducing” an immigrant to come or remain in the United States unlawfully. According to the Court, the law does not run afoul of the First Amendment. The Court further found that the context and the statutory text both supported its interpretation.

Immigration 52

Immigration Court Statute Construction 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

JUNE 22, 2023

Supreme Court held that the government can’t keep the profits of properties sold to satisfy tax debts. The District Court dismissed the suit for failure to state a claim, and the Eighth Circuit affirmed. Supreme Court’s Decision The Supreme Court reversed. The Court first addressed the issue of standing.

Court 52

Court Real Estate Government Constitutional Law 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

AUGUST 28, 2023

Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of state laws requiring corporations operating within their borders to consent to personal jurisdiction when they register to do business in those states. According to the Court, such laws do not offend the Constitution’s Due Process Clause. In Mallory v. Bauman , 571 U.S.

Court 52

Court Laws Cause of Action Constitutional Law 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

JULY 19, 2023

Supreme Court held that to establish that a statement is a “true threat” unprotected by the First Amendment, the state must prove that the defendant had some subjective understanding of the statements’ threatening nature, based on a showing no more demanding than recklessness. The Colorado Supreme Court denied review. In Counterman v.

Mens Rea 52

Mens Rea Court Constitutional Law Statute 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

JUNE 5, 2023

Supreme Court rejected a constitutional challenge to a California animal welfare law that requires pork sold in the state to come from humanely raised pigs. According to the Court, the law did not violate the dormant commerce clause in regulating the pork industry outside California. We decline that invitation.

Laws 52

Laws Court Constitutional Law Court Decisions 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

APRIL 4, 2023

Supreme Court held that the penalty for the nonwillful failure to file a Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR) is $10,000 per report rather than per account. The statute imposes a maximum $10,000 penalty for nonwillful violations of the law. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals agreed with the government’s assessment.

Court 59

Court Statute Government Calendaring 59

Constitutional Law Reporter

MARCH 14, 2023

Supreme Court held that debts incurred by fraud can’t be discharged in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, even if a debtor wasn’t culpable for the fraud. Justice Amy Coney Barrett wrote on behalf of the unanimous Court. Buckley sued in California state court and won, leaving the Bartenwerfers jointly responsible for more than $200,000 in damages.

Court 52

Court Constitutional Law Statute Court Decisions 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

APRIL 30, 2024

Supreme Court held that the State of Georgia can’t retry a defendant acquitted of murder by reason of insanity. We simply cannot know why the jury in McElrath’s case acted as it did, and the Double Jeopardy Clause forbids us to guess,” the Court held. “To The Georgia courts rejected that argument, and McElrath appealed to the U.S.

Felony 59

Felony Court Constitutional Law Laws 59

Constitutional Law Reporter

JUNE 17, 2024

Supreme Court held that the Copyright Act entitles a copyright owner to obtain monetary relief for any timely infringement claim, no matter when the infringement occurred. The Court did not address when copyright infringement claims accrue with regard to the statute of limitations. The District Court agreed.

Diligence 52

Diligence Statute Court Constitutional Law 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

MAY 14, 2024

Supreme Court held that the Federal Arbitration Act’s (FAA) exemption for transportation workers in interstate commerce applies to transportation workers regardless of whether they work in the transportation industry. Supreme Court’s Decision The Supreme Court unanimously reversed. “A In Bissonnette v. Adams , 532 U.S.

Contract 52

Contract Court Construction Constitutional Law 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

JUNE 25, 2024

Supreme Court ruled that the National Rifle Association (NRA) may continue its First Amendment lawsuit against the former head of New York’s Department of Financial Services. The Supreme Court also reaffirmed its holding in Bantam Books, Inc. Finally, the Court emphasized the limits of its ruling.

Government 52

Government Court Constitutional Law Contract 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

FEBRUARY 28, 2022

Supreme Court allowed Alabama to implement a congressional redistricting map that includes only one district with a majority of Black voters. While a lower court agreed with challengers that the map constitutes illegal racial gerrymandering, the Supreme Court granted a stay, effectively putting the order on hold.

Court 52

Court Constitutional Law Laws Court Decisions 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

MAY 29, 2024

Supreme Court held that a traffic impact fee imposed by the County of El Dorado based on a fee schedule in the County’s General Plan ran afoul of the Constitution’s Takings Clause. The trial court rejected Sheetz’s claim, and the California Court of Appeal affirmed. In Sheetz v. City of Tigard , 512 U.S.

Government 52

Government Court Constitutional Law Court Decisions 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

DECEMBER 27, 2023

Supreme Court recently issued the term’s first decision in an argued case. Laufer , 601 U.S. _ (2023), the Court unanimously held the case is moot, declining to reach a closely watched issue of “tester” standing under the Americans With Disabilities Act (ADA). The Supreme Court granted review to address the split.

Court 52

Court Constitutional Law Lawyer Lawyers 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

APRIL 25, 2024

Supreme Court held that Yonas Fikre’s lawsuit against the FBI is not moot. Accordingly, his suit alleging that the government placed him on the No Fly List unlawfully may proceed in the lower courts. The district court agreed with the government, but the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed.

Government 52

Government Court Constitutional Law Court Decisions 52

SCOTUSBlog

APRIL 14, 2021

Ask any constitutional law student to name the most iconic Supreme Court decision, and they’ll probably answer Marbury v. Those two landmark rulings stand as the most celebrated decisions the court has ever issued. Maryland : “[W]e must never forget that it is a constitution we are expounding.”

Court 106

Court Education Constitutional Law Court Decisions 106

LLRX

MAY 30, 2022

Wade has been settled law during her entire career. In this article Biehl succinctly and expertly identifies how the upcoming Supreme Court decision in Dobbs V. Kathy Biehl is a lawyer licensed in two states, as well as a prolific multidisciplinary author and writer.

Drafting 102

Drafting Court Decisions Lawyer Lawyers 102

Constitutional Law Reporter

SEPTEMBER 25, 2023

Supreme Court struck down the college admissions programs of Harvard University and the University of North Carolina. The Court held that the raced-based policies violated the Constitution’s Equal Protection Clause. In both cases, the lower courts upheld the admissions policies, and Students for Fair Admissions appealed.

Court 52

Court Constitutional Law Education Court Decisions 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

SEPTEMBER 19, 2023

Supreme Court held that the False Claims Act’s scienter element — which asks whether a defendant “knowingly” submitted a “false” claim to the government — refers to a defendant’s knowledge and subjective beliefs — not to what an objectively reasonable person may have known or believed. SuperValu Inc. , S. _ (2023), the U.S.

Court 52

Court Constitutional Law Court Rules Court Decisions 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

APRIL 18, 2023

Supreme Court held that a deaf student seeking compensatory damages under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) for the denial of a free and appropriate education may proceed without exhausting the administrative processes of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) because the remedy sought is not one IDEA provides.

Compensatory Damages 59

Compensatory Damages Education Statute Court 59

Constitutional Law Reporter

AUGUST 9, 2023

Supreme Court modified the religious accommodation standard under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, which requires employers to accommodate the religious practice of their employees unless doing so would impose an “undue hardship on the conduct of the employer’s business.” The District Court granted summary judgment to USPS.

Court 52

Court Construction Constitutional Law Court Decisions 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

MAY 1, 2023

Supreme Court held that the Quiet Title Act’s statute of limitations is a claim-processing rule rather than a bright-line rule that constrains a court’s jurisdiction. Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote on behalf of the Court. Supreme Court’s Decision The Supreme Court reversed by a vote of 6-3.

Government 52

Government Statute Entertainment Constitutional Law 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

MAY 10, 2023

Supreme Court has concluded its oral arguments for the 2022-2023 Term. The Court’s final week included four cases, with issues ranging from bankruptcy to RICO to government takings. Below is a brief summary of the issues before the Court: Lac du Flambeau Band of Lake Superior Chippewa Indians v. 2d 1112, 1115 (7th Cir.

Government 59

Government Statute Court Legal 59

Constitutional Law Reporter

JUNE 26, 2023

Supreme Court unanimously found that when an alleged trademark infringer uses the mark as a designation of source for its own goods or services the threshold test for expressive works established in Rogers v. Justice Elena Kagan wrote on behalf of the unanimous Court. VIP Products LLC , 599 U.S. _ (2023), the U.S. Grimaldi , 875 F.

Court 59

Court Constitutional Law Court Decisions Laws 59

Constitutional Law Reporter

AUGUST 28, 2023

Supreme Court unanimously held that the Constitution permits the retrial of a defendant following a trial in an improper venue conducted before a jury drawn from the wrong district. The District Court concluded that factual disputes related to venue should be resolved by the jury and denied Smith’s motion to dismiss without prejudice.

Court 52

Court Constitutional Law Court Decisions Laws 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

FEBRUARY 16, 2023

Supreme Court issued its first opinion of the 2022-2023 Term. S. _ (2023), a unanimous Court held that the effective date of an award of service-related disability compensation to a veteran of the United States military determined pursuant to 38 U.S.C. §§ 5110(a)(1) and 5110(b)(1) is not subject to equitable tolling. In Arellano v.

Statute 52

Statute Diligence Court Constitutional Law 52

Constitutional Law Reporter

AUGUST 16, 2023

Supreme Court unanimously held that the Constitution permits the retrial of a defendant following a trial in an improper venue conducted before a jury drawn from the wrong district. The District Court concluded that factual disputes related to venue should be resolved by the jury and denied Smith’s motion to dismiss without prejudice.

Court 52

Court Constitutional Law Court Decisions Laws 52

Conflict of Laws

DECEMBER 21, 2023

SYMPOSIUM: Fundamental Rights and Private International Law Ralf Michaels: Einleitung zum Symposium: Grundrechte und IPR im Lichte der Entscheidung des Bundesverfassungsgerichts zum Kinderehenbekämpfungsgesetz, 707–713, DOI: [link] [Open Access: CC BY-SA 4.0] These questions invite further inquiry and academic exchange.

Contract 59

Contract Constitutional Law Laws Legal 59

Constitutional Law Reporter

APRIL 11, 2023

Supreme Court held that uncashed MoneyGram checks are governed by the Disposition of Abandoned Money Orders and Traveler’s Check Act (FDA) and should be returned to the state where they were issued. According to the Court, the Disputed Instruments share two relevant similarities with money orders. In Delaware v.

Constitutional Law 59

Constitutional Law Statute Court Government 59

Constitutional Law Reporter

JUNE 1, 2023

Supreme Court held that death row inmate Rodney Reed did not wait too long to seek DNA testing of the evidence in his case. According to the Court majority, when a prisoner pursues state post-conviction DNA testing through the state-provided litigation process, the statute of limitations for a 42 U.S.C.

Statute 52

Statute Litigation Litigating Cause of Action 52

At the Lectern

AUGUST 7, 2022

In separate opinions on Friday, the Ninth Circuit affirmed the denial of habeas corpus petitions filed by two prisoners whose death sentences the California Supreme Court upheld almost 30 years ago. The divided decision was in Fauber v. Davis , which comes after the Supreme Court affirmed the death penalty for a 1986 murder ( People v.

Constitutional Law 49

Constitutional Law Court Decisions Court Laws 49

Broadcast Law Blog

MARCH 16, 2017

The Florida case has been referred to that state’s highest court for an advisory ruling on the state of the state’s law on the issue, and earlier this week, the same thing happened in California. A decision on this issue in any state is binding only in that state.

Court 40

Court Constitutional Law Laws Court Decisions 40