article thumbnail

Truth, Lies and Plea Bargaining

The Crime Report

For example, a collection of evidence about a single felony offense will be broken down into separate misdemeanor offenses labeled as separate “acts.” Even though a judge, prosecutor and defendant agree it was only one criminal act, the multiple misdemeanors would be honored to lessen the penalty, yet still get a semblance of justice.

article thumbnail

Insurance statute did not create private right of action for general contractor

Day on Torts

In Affordable Construction Services, Inc. 56-7-111 states that “when an insured property owner’s home or other structure sustains more than $1,000 in damages, the property or casualty insurance company shall name the general contractor of an uncompleted construction contract as a payee when issuing payment to the owner for the loss.”

Statute 59
Insiders

Sign Up for our Newsletter

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

article thumbnail

“An argument for zero-based state constitutional interpretation”

At the Lectern

5th 998, the court unanimously found a state constitutional right to appointed counsel for a misdemeanor defendant who is the respondent in a prosecution appeal of an order suppressing evidence. Supreme Court has said or might say. In Gardner v. Appellate Division (2019) 6 Cal.5th ” ( Id. ’ ” (6 Cal.5th ’ ” ( Id.

article thumbnail

Federal judge sentences Florida man for conspiring to firebomb Planned Parenthood clinic

JURIST

According to the DOJ’s statement, Batten conspired with Chance Brannon and Tibet Ergul, both from California, to construct a Molotov cocktail which was later detonated in a Planned Parenthood clinic in Costa Mesa, California. The events leading to Batten’s sentence transpired in February and March of 2022.

article thumbnail

Court expands government’s ability to deport noncitizens for offenses related to obstruction of justice

SCOTUSBlog

Finally, concluding that the statute’s meaning was unambiguous after applying traditional rules of statutory construction, Kavanaugh declined to apply the rule of lenity, which resolves any ambiguity in criminal or immigration statutes in favor of the criminal defendant or the noncitizen.

Felony 104
article thumbnail

Four cases on the February calendar, including one that’s the answer to a trivia question

At the Lectern

Fresno Unified School District : When the court granted review in March 2021 , it limited the issue to: “Is a lease-leaseback arrangement in which construction is financed through bond proceeds rather than by or through the builder a ‘contract’ within the meaning of Government Code section 53511?” (See here and here.) In re F.M. :

article thumbnail

Supreme Court takes three cases and depublishes three opinions; dissenting votes in four review denials

At the Lectern

83 — and where the Attorney General has knowledge of, or is in actual or constructive possession of, such evidence — what duty, if any, does the Attorney General have to acknowledge or disclose that evidence to the petitioner? Maryland (1963) 373 U.S. Would any such duty be triggered only upon issuance of an order to show cause?

Court 49