article thumbnail

Subjective intent of wrongdoing required to convict doctors under Controlled Substances Act

SCOTUSBlog

In arguing a subjective standard is required, the charged doctors and other advocates emphasized longstanding rules about the presumption of mens rea (a guilty state of mind) for criminal offenses. A mens rea requirement, the opinion holds, is essential to separate physicians’ “socially beneficial conduct” from criminal conduct.

Mens Rea 101
article thumbnail

In opioids “pill mill” case, justices grapple with physician intent

SCOTUSBlog

Justice Brett Kavanaugh suggested the regulation could be helpfully clarified — a suggestion the government’s lawyer, Deputy Solicitor General Eric Feigin, resisted, noting that the language in the regulation tracks language in the statute and that it would be difficult to improve on it.

Insiders

Sign Up for our Newsletter

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

article thumbnail

Why Do We Treat Sex Crimes Differently Than Other Violent Crimes?

The Crime Report

“I’m kind of saying to people, you think that this is like enlightenment, creating more sex crimes every day, getting tougher on sex crimes, but look at some of the history, even the recent history and you start to question that instinct,” Gruber said of her research.

Mens Rea 140
article thumbnail

Meeting of the Minds: The Price of Recklessness: Disgorgement of Pro?ts in a Post-Romag World

The IP Law Blog

While the argument that “principles of equity” includes a willfulness requirement would not “directly contradict the statute’s other, express mens rea provisions or render them wholly superfluous[,]. companies and their lawyers have considered tort litigation in China pointless. litigation in U.S. cation more difficult.

article thumbnail

SCOTUS dispatch: government lawyer grilled for an hour on meaning of federal corruption statute

JURIST

It is truly—as a former government lawyer—baffling how someone say that [the definition of corruptly] was not contested, that this [gratuity] was wrongful. “Corruptly” as a consciousness of wrongdoing has never been the mens rea for bribery. Rebuttal “At least we should get a 9-0 remand today,” Ms.

Statute 129
article thumbnail

Detailed Analysis of POCSO Act, 2012

LexForti

Lawyers often fight for postponements due to extraneous factors, and if the sufferer is summoned to trial again six to seven months following the event, their memory of the particular specifics of the incident may get blurred as a result of the postponement.

Statute 52
article thumbnail

Biden Critics Say Change to Trump ‘Mens Rea’ Reform Endangers Innocent

The Crime Report

The order recognized that executive agencies have promulgated “thousands of regulations, creating a thicket of requirements that can be difficult to navigate,” and sought to make sure that all regulatory criminal laws are “clearly written so that all Americans can understand what is prohibited and act accordingly.”.